Strong support for President Donald Trump’s immigration agenda appears to have peaked, with more voters than not now giving him a thumbs down amid talk of amnesty for farm workers and concerns about Florida’s “Alligator Alcatraz.”
In the latest Rasmussen Reports survey of likely voters on Trump’s handling of immigration, he is upside down with 45% giving him a “good to excellent” grade and 52% a “fair to poor” score.
Notably, 34% said the president was doing an “excellent” job while 44% said his performance has been “poor.”
Partisans took their usual positions. Republicans approved of Trump’s agenda of closing the border and deporting illegal immigrants in the United States by 76% while 78% of Democrats opposed him.
However, independents disapprove of Trump’s job. Some 39% gave him a good to excellent rating, and 56% gave him a fair to poor grade.
While the survey analysis did not cite why Trump is underwater on his hallmark issue, the poll was conducted after the president started talking about giving migrant farm and hospitality workers a break from his national crackdown. That has led to critics claiming he plans to give those workers “amnesty” from his agenda.
I was reliably informed by Ms. Rollins herself that there would be NO AMNESTY.
So IDK what this is about. https://t.co/RtNZEZZbOG
— Mark Mitchell, Rasmussen Reports (@honestpollster) July 11, 2025
Trump has been forced to deny that he favors amnesty, and his top immigration aides have also been sent out to reject suggestions that the administration favors amnesty for any illegal immigrants.
The new survey shared with Secrets also showed that voters are split over “Alligator Alcatraz,” the makeshift holding prison for illegal immigrants that the administration plans to deport.
SEE THE LATEST POLITICAL NEWS AND BUZZ FROM WASHINGTON SECRETS
When asked if they approve of the new facility, 48% of likely voters said they did, compared to 46% who don’t.
“‘Alligator Alcatraz’ divides voters,” said Rasmussen’s analysis. “The Trump administration’s plan to detain illegal immigrants at a site in the Florida Everglades dubbed ‘Alligator Alcatraz’ is popular with Republican voters, but not so much with others,” it added, noting that 80% of the GOP approve of it while 69% of Democrats and 52% of independents don’t.